Review of Bernt Stellander's book: 'The Sudden Impulse'
MY FIRST READ THROUGH:
First.
It is a BIG BOOK. 24 x 16 x 4.5. [Clarke’s is a conventional B format paper back 20 x 13 x 2]
It has 850 pages [Clarke’s - 273]
It is heavy, at 1.55 kg. [Clarke's - 300g]
It is heavy, at 1.55 kg. [Clarke's - 300g]
It contains ca. 440,000 words. [Clarke’s est. ca 135,000]
The cover and the paper are of a higher specification than normal
The glue for the binding is very thick.
The glue for the binding is very thick.
Confession:
It is so heavy and so thick and so stiff I confess I chopped my copy into three volumes.
The second part of the book is conveniently the final 250 pages, and the first two thirds divide neatly at page 274
It takes some doing. Sharp Swiss army knife and several passes through the thick glue and the glossy card cover, but it is worth the effort and the sacrifice for you then have a THREE volume Dissertation, [each one longer than Clarke’s] that you can open, hold in comfort and read.
The contents pages lay out his approach.
He adopts the method of ‘argumentum ad absurdum’ a form of questioning so beloved of Socrates and other philosophers since.
Start by accepting unquestioningly what the ‘witnesses’ say and see where the logic takes you.
I used it in my chapter 5 for example
GM said he was in the apartment, saw M and left at 2113
JT said she saw the “abductor’ carrying M at 2115
THEREFORE everything necessary had to happen between those two times.
And since there very clearly is not enough time, the argumentum is absurdum
The response can be two fold. The protagonist may realise the absurdity and admit error,
OR, as in this case, may seek to change, or add details, to include for example the even more absurd suggestion of the abductor’s already being in the apartment hiding behind a door. The fact that the door in question opens flush against the wall being conveniently not mentioned.
Socrates might have asked a supplementary question but here there is no need. The whole thing has been exposed as untrue.
Bernt Stellander relentlessly pursues and dissects each important part in the McCanns’ and Tapas’ statements in the first half kilo of the book (274 pages) exposing the absurdities and contradictions between and among them.
Of course much of this has been done before, but piecemeal. This is a whole ‘volume’ – longer than Clarke’s entire book – dedicated to this one issue. It is comprehensive and compelling, however familiar many of us are with the examples he chooses.
In the second half kilo (328 pages) Stellander addresses the issue of when the death occurred.
Most people by now realise that “during the evening of Thursday 3rd” is not possible for the reasons we all know which he sets out again.
Many researchers have come to their own more or less tentative conclusions about the order of events during the week. Stellander builds on them and weaves in various of the more coherent statements to arrive at Wednesday [edited] 2nd May. Some may not agree, but his logic seems good.
He makes the point that there is a lot of evidence pointing to 2 May. Is it likely for example, that Gerry would have messed up the script so much even if he had just one more day, never mind the three days which others, INCLUDING MYSELF have proposed.
Gerry would have ensured, again for example, that Jane was not confused between blindly following the script or ‘telling the story”. But she was, and we saw her burst into tears during the Mock reconstruction, when she realised she had got it all wrong, and compromised the whole thing by placing herself walking past Jez and Gerry, something Gerry would and could have prevented if given more time.
And we remember Kate telling us how crucial it was for her to get on record in her diary/ journal everything FROM 3 May. Again perhaps speaking the truth, as any focus on 2 May would destroy them.
He then commits to paper his theory of what the sequence was from that point, the sequestration of the body, and the subsequent burial in its final resting place, giving dates.
He goes into details about why he believes the grave is where it is, using for the most part Kate’s statements, diary, and interviews. He interprets them as ‘leakage’ in line with ‘statement analysis’ and then shows where the widely reported, publicised and photographed runs up the hill in the matching outfits, complete with carefully timings fit into the deception.
Then the final half kilo. Worth its weight in gold, if only for the account of his nocturnal activities, his searches, his lying in wait under bushes and in a small cave for nights on end.
He starts by predicting their return around the anniversary, publicised by Kate in her book and many women’s magazines and the gutter press. And he was correct.
He sets up “Trail cams”, and tells the story of his struggles to make them work and not ‘alert’ to blades of grass moving with the breeze.
He then details a series of anonymous emails he sends to the McCanns, alerting them to the possibility that the ‘site’ had been discovered.
On cue they walk into the frame and are caught on camera. NOT in running kit.
And so on
I shall stop here, so as not to ruin the surprises to come.
The photos are not included in the book, but are promised on two websites, which are under construction.
The chosen locations however, are included.
Throughout the book he expresses sympathy for the parents, not only for the accidental death of their first born child, but for the impossible and grave situation they all, including the Tapas 7, and many others are trapped due to what he calls ‘a Sudden Impulse’.
Gerry. “Sometimes people do things for reasons that even they cannot understand”
“An act of madness and accident or a sudden impulse could lead to consequences that people may never have imagined or intended”
“faced with such a situation we believe any human soul ultimately suffer torment and feelings of guilt and fear”
He has great sympathy towards Kate, who he believes, as many of us do, has been suffering torment and feelings of guilt and fear, having lost her child and her profession. Almost everything she has said after 3/5/7 reveals a desire to tell the truth, to speak out, “to shout it from the roof tops”.
As Stellander points out, even in the forward of her own book she tells us she cannot tell the whole truth, Just a “version of it”.
Kate; Book p.2 “On the whole Gerry and I have managed to dig deep and remain focused although the temptation to shout the truth from the rooftops has always been there. There have been many times when I have struggled to keep myself together and to understand how such injustices of been allowed to go unchallenged over and over again. I have had to keep saying to myself: I know the truth, we know the truth, and God knows the truth. And one day the truth will out. [but not today nor in this book! PM. ] Publishing the truth is fraught with risks for our family. It leaves us open to more criticism for a start.”
His wish is that the revelations in this book allow them - all - to confess, and to atone for what they have done.
FOOTNOTE:
It is of course purely coincidental that Stellander’s announcement that the Book launch was to be on 2/5/24, his anniversary date, and that the McCanns for the first time in 17 years decided not to attend the Service in Rothley to mark their anniversary date, but instead went on ‘holiday’ to a “secret resort"
Tracy Kandohla : “Mr Brian Kennedy - Maddie’s great uncle, [“Fund mostly for Legal expenses,”] -said … “Kate and Gerry have gone away, they didn't tell me where and I didn’t ask, and it is a bit of a clash. But they work very hard and they needed a break very much.”
Pure coincidence, Obviously.
(Except that he had sent a personal email to Kate the day before the 2 May event.)
----------------------------------
Letter from PeterMac to Operation Grange dated 6th May re: Bernt Stellander, The Foreign Detective's, new book 'The Sudden Impulse'
Gentlemen,
May we assume you are aware of the recently published book in Portuguese and English :-
The Sudden Impulse, by Berndt Stellander, available from the publishers
Modocromia, [email: modocromia.editora@gmail.com]
in which he details an operation he conducted over many years, finding the site of Madeleine’s grave and CRUCIALLY, filming the McCanns and their friends visiting it to check on several occasions, when he had anonymously alerted them to the possibility that it had been found.
That film will shortly be released on websites set up for the purpose.
The press in Germany and elsewhere has run the story of the launch of the book, and of the Q&A session afterwards.
The British Press has of course not referred to it even obliquely, in line with the very obvious gagging order which has clearly been in place for a long time, and which may even control your activity.
Whether you are permitted to “investigate” is unclear.
I do not need to point out that this information is in line with the PJ’s investigation and the decisions of the Appeal and the Supreme Courts of Portugal and the ECHR,- who all concluded that there was no abduction, and that the parents concealed the body, but I do so, in order that when I receive your automatically generated acknowledgement it will be clear that the information was in your hands for any future FIO requests about the way in which the Operation has been directed.
It incidentally makes the “Fund” a very simple case of Fraud, an offence known to English Law, and committed in England.
You may wish to draw this to the attention of your Commanding Officer.
Yours sincerely
Peter MacLeod
retired Police Superintendent - Nottingham 1972-2000
[my name will be in your files as having sent large amounts of documentation over the years]
copied to various other investigators
From: Operation.grange@met.police.uk
Date: 6 May 2024 at 20:34:03 CEST
To: pmacleod****@*****.com
Subject: Automated Response
Related links:
Many thanks for taking the time to contact the Operation Grange mailbox.
Your email will be read by one of the officers on the enquiry team. You will appreciate that we receive a large volume of emails as part of this enquiry and as a result you may not necessarily receive any further contact from us. If, however we need to contact you further, an officer will be in touch in due course.
NOTICE - This email and any attachments are solely for the intended recipient and may be confidential. If you have received this email in error, please notify the sender and delete it from your system. Do not use, copy or disclose the information contained in this email or in any attachment without the permission of the sender. Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) communication systems are monitored to the extent permitted by law and any email and/or attachments may be read by monitoring staff. Only specified personnel are authorised to conclude binding agreements on behalf of the MPS by email and no responsibility is accepted for unauthorised agreements reached with other personnel. While reasonable precautions have been taken to ensure no viruses are present in this email, its security and that of any attachments cannot be guaranteed.- Letter from PeterMac to Operation Grange dated 6th May re: Bernt Stellander, The Foreign Detective's, new book 'The Sudden Impulse' (forumotion.net)
- Norwegian ex-military detective claims to have solved Madeleine case (forumotion.net)
- New Madeleine McCann book will claim missing tot is already dead (forumotion.net)